- How Revolutionary is Obama's Anti-FISA Group?
- Daily Digest: You're Not the Boss of Me Now...
- The FISA Protest and myBO: Can We Talk? Can They Listen?
- McCain: Untapped YouTube Talent?
- Anti-Telecom Immunity Group Tops MyBarackObama.com
- Daily Digest: Next for FISA on MyBO? "Don't Ask Me"
- UK Shows the Way Toward Public Data 2.0
- PdF2008: Edwards, Lessig, Zittrain, Pesce Keynotes Are Up on Pdf.Blip.tv
- New Political Patterns in Book-Buying
- Daily Digest: Millennials of the World, Unite!
By David All, 04/10/2007 - 1:40pm
Earlier this morning (and aired on C-SPAN2), Newt Gingrich and Sen. John Kerry held a "debate on Global Climate Change, specifically carbons in the atmosphere," in the Russell Senate Office Building on Capitol Hill.
John and Newt debated two views for an American solution to help reduce carbons emissions. The debate wasn't moderated; but was rather an open dialogue-style debate of back and forth question and response.
This format is something Newt Gingrich called for after watching the media swarm on the YouTube Hillary Clinton "Big Sister" ad which now has over 3 million views. In calling for very real conversations about the future of America (instead of 30 second spots), Gingrich said (YouTube video):
“There is not a single thing in that commercial that enables America to solve a problem. Oh, it’s clever…fills up space in television…people can talk about it. It’s the Entertainment Tonight version of governing a great country, and it’s very dangerous." He then challenges the respective Nominees for President of each Party to a weekly, 90-minute dialogue, from Labor Day to the Election…”two adults, the future of America, and a conversation.”
So Newt posed a solution to a problem (issues being reduced to clever ads). And Senator John Kerry accepted. Porridge to both of them.
So what about the substance of their debate? Well, as you know, I don't watch TV unless it's a clip someone sends to me on YouTube or a show on my DVR. But Matt Keller of the Draft Newt team live-blogged it and sent me a quick summary of his thoughts for your reading pleasure:
Senator Kerry’s viewpoint was that of imposing more government regulations on industry while Speaker Gingrich’s approach was to give tax incentives to the marketplace, to stimulate green technological growth.
I think the most important thing to take out of the debate, was the difference in tone and quality of the non moderated debate vs. the kind of debate we see in Presidential contests. John Kerry and Newt Gingrich were warm and friendly to each other; they were engaging each other’s minds as well as the audience. The conversation was genuine.
The other key aspect was the changing nature of the debate, toward the end both sides found common ground. John Kerry stated that he and Speaker Gingrich could work together to form a hybrid plan in an effort to control carbon emissions. The debate proved that Newt’s model for American Solutions is on the right path. It is the Ideas generated through these debates that will provide Solutions tomorrow.
This is interesting. Two strong minds (yes, I'm being bipartisan) held a debate/discussion about how best to solve a problem which everyone cares about (in some way). And instead of reciting partisan rhetoric and vehemently opposing the other guy, they actually found some common-ground. That's good news.
Could Newt and John be re-inventing the Presidential debate?
more from David All's blog | login or register to post comments
Recent blog posts
Recent comments
- Obama has anti-FISA dissent trapped........
44 min 11 sec ago - Stunning
4 hours 38 min ago - Poll Driven versus Social Network Driven
5 hours 43 min ago - Solution
19 hours 23 min ago - 17,590 and Counting
21 hours 40 min ago - Unsheathing the YouTube Sword
22 hours 30 min ago - Opt out of email
1 day 1 hour ago - Alternative Reason For High Number of Views
1 day 1 hour ago - Worthy
1 day 1 hour ago - The Premise of the Poll
2 days 36 min ago
Most Emailed
- The FISA Protest and myBO: Can We Talk? Can They Listen?
- Daily Digest: PdF '08 Roundup -- Crickets Seem to Greet "McCain is Aware of the Internet" Meme
- PdF2008: BREAKING: "John McCain is Aware of the Internet"
- Open Systems, Closed Systems and Trauma in the Press
- Daily Digest: PdF '08 Day One -- And So It Begins

print
email
delicious
digg
technorati
Or...
Sorry to be cynical, but this seems like a joint exercise in irrelevance. They're not keeping debate alive, their debate is keeping them alive (or in the news, at least).
I can't speak for Gingrich or the right, but Kerry doesn't really carry much weight on the left.