So, instead of using text messages (aka "SMS" for Short Message Service) you can use MMS (Multimedia Messaging Service) for images, audio video & rich text. Soon we will see such announcements including images and a personal audio message, maybe even a short MMS video. -Rich Sr./Cellyspace.com
By David All, 08/23/2008 - 9:14pm
"Brilliant. Effective. Revolutionary."
Those are the three words I thought I'd write in response to Barack Obama's text message announcing his Vice Presidential pick. Instead, the only word that comes to mind is "Disappointing."
Let me explain...
Having upgraded recently from a BlackBerry to a white 3G iPhone I went ahead and signed up on my new line for the updates. More text messages? No worries, I had already opted for the unlimited text plan so that I could better follow about a dozen or so folks on Twitter without having to track mileage.
I ripped off the text like a pro -- tapping "VP" to 62262 and clicking send. Within seconds I received a response back from 62262 letting me know that the sign-up was a success.
Noting in my little black book of best practices that even the confirmation note had a call to action ("Please forward"), I cracked a smile in recognition of the genius of Obama online guru Joe Rospars and his team.
I thought, could the be the text that's heard around the world as it got forwarded from an initial few to many? What would the text say?
I was pumped and excited for the text. And I'm a Republican who will not vote for Barack Obama regardless of his running mate.
The promise of direct, exclusive information sent to my iPhone was a heckuva carrot to put out on a stick. Not just for me -- but for others too. In fact, last week when I was training 60 field representatives for the College Republicans (a client) I asked the room who else had signed up -- at least a quarter of the hands slowly grabbed the sky.
Days went by last week since I had signed up. I hadn't received a single text from Barack. Was this thing still working? Indeed, a Tweet would pop up reminding me that the foot was still on the pedal. I even thought it was genius that Barack's team had not sent a text to me. I had signed up for one text, at least initially -- don't break the promise or risk losing me.
So... I... Waited... For... Barack...
After a long week at work, I decided to forget about it for the night. I went out with friends, had sushi, saki, and laughs. I went to bed.
When I woke up this morning, I grabbed my iPhone to start reading through late night tweets, text messages, and emails. OMG. WTH is that? a text message from Barack at 3:04 AM? No way...
Confirmed. It was indeed from Obama's campaign -- but it wasn't from Barack -- the person. The text was from Barack Obama -- the Machine.
Using 148 of their 160-character limit the Machine wrote:
Barack has chosen Senator Joe Biden to be our VP nominee. Watch the first Obama-Biden rally live at 3 PM ET on www.BarackObama.com. Spread the word!
What were they thinking by not using Barack's voice? Didn't they realize that I'm used to getting very real, personal text messages from my friends? Didn't they know that even I thought that Barack really "got" this modern medium?
Patrick Ruffini blogged this morning that Barack's text wasn't even really worth the wait because it had leaked to the media beforehand. To quote Patrick, "What seemed like a brilliant exercise in media management devolved into a late night rearguard maneuver." Agreed.
So, if I were working for Barack, I would have suggested the following 160-character text (Leave no character behind!):
Senator Joe Biden is my VP pick. Visit www.BarackObama.com now to see a video message from us to you. You are an important part of the Team for Change. Plz fwd!
But... They didn't. Barack didn't text me anything. The Machine did.
I'm disappointed in Barack's team for missing this opportunity to communicate a direct, personal message from Barack and Joe to their people.
So points for using text messaging as a medium to communicate; however, they're just not doing a good job of using it effectively.
[Cross-posted from TechRepublican.]
more from David All's blog | login or register to post comments
Recent blog posts
- Bridging another Digital Divide: Local races and DLCCWeb
- Defense Department Voting Assistance Program Draws Congressional Fire
- Daily Digest: Obama as Clinton Redux, in More Ways Than One
- Change.gov Swaps Traditional Copyright for Creative Commons
- Obama's Production Tweaks
- Clinton Successor Watch: RFK Jr.'s Facebook Group
- Daily Digest: Did the Internet Matter?
- Change.gov a Wiki Wannabe
- Daily Digest: Obama Looking Eager to Open 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue
- Change.gov Starts to Go Interactive, Intensively
Recent comments
- So very early in the going
2 hours 51 min ago - Manual trackback
3 hours 7 min ago - I have been looking for
9 hours 47 min ago - Thank you for your site. I
9 hours 49 min ago - change.com
9 hours 52 min ago - Good step, but...
19 hours 49 min ago - thanks
2 days 4 hours ago - Forum Federation
2 days 6 hours ago - Tim O'Reilly seems to agree...
3 days 16 min ago - the game is still bottom-up
3 days 1 hour ago

print
email
delicious
digg
technorati
Email vs. SMS
Barack's team missed an enormous opportunity to communicate personally, to me, from Barack.
I think such pretense can work in email, where distinct "voices" can be reinforced over time, and where the From: name is easily set. So the candidate emails about The Big Things, the campaign manager about the political landscape and state of the race, the finance director about fundraising numbers, the field director about volunteering, etc.
But SMS is limited to 160 characters, and there is no From: line. The text message wasn't coming from Barack's personal cell phone number. It came from 62262, the campaign's short code. All users know that Obama himself isn't sending millions of individual text messages. They know that the campaign uses a service to do such a thing.
As such, the campaign just cut the pretense and spoke from the campaign voice. They've done the same for their past messages I've received: "Watch Barack and Hillary together in Unity, NH" and "Watch Barack live in Berlin".
SMS is a very restrictive medium, and I think the decision to embrace those constraints rather than act outwardly phony was a good one by the Obama campaign.