My video response to John Edwards
By stevegarfield, 05/02/2007 - 2:41pm

John Edwards just sent me an email that prompted me to act.

The email asked me to contribute money to help him put an ad, about ending the war, on TV in Washington. I didn't do that.

It also asked me to create a video. That I did.

Edwards says:

I asked my staff to create an emergency television ad that would bring the people's voice directly to Congress, calling on them to make the right choice. They worked late into the night and we now have a powerful message ready to go on the air in D.C. as soon as tomorrow morning.

I get lots of emails similar to this one. They always ask for money to put an ad on TV, and I always wonder why they don't encourage people to spread the videos on line.

This time the ad is up on YouTube, and there is something different at the end of the email too.

Edwards asks people to contribute to the ad by recording video of themselves saying "We the People":

We've designed the ad so you can actually add yourself in online. We hope that dozens, hundreds or even thousands of people will send in video clips of themselves echoing the message of the ad — "We the people" are asking Congress to stand up to Bush.

This makes it very easy to participate and collaborate with the campaign to send a message to Washington.

Anyone with a webcam can post a video response. People are already discussing the ad's merits, in the comments, on YouTube.

I'll be interested to see how many video responses get posted. They've made it easy to participate and it's an issue that a lot of people feel strongly about. At this early stage of the campaign, I think a lot of people like myself who haven't yet decided on a candidate, might contribute to this video, since it's more about the issue, and less about endorsing a candidate.

The campaign has it set up so that video responses will be posted after they have been approved by the video owner.

Read more here - John Edwards: We The People.

Great idea, but YouTube falls short

This video is a great example of the type of rapid response video that we're going to see over the next two years.

However, YouTube is not the appropriate host for the video. Here's the problem, when the video is embedded onto a site like Steve did in his post above, YouTube ends the video with two options: watch again and forward to a friend. But as Steve noted, that's not the intended purpose of the video, it's real ask is to accumulate donations and get people to upload their own video.

YouTube doesn't allow users to embed their own clickable ads. Blip.tv does, so does Veoh.com. Campaigns should become fluent in content delivery systems and not just throw their videos on YouTube. Blip and veoh would expand the viral effect of the video by giving all viewers, not just those on the email list the same opportunity to take the desired action of uploading video and making a donation.

Hey Jason, YouTube allows

Hey Jason,
YouTube allows people to post a video response right from YouTube without having to use any video editing software. That's powerful.

YouTube does mess up the end of the video by overwriting it with the watch again or forward graphic, but if people are looking at the video on John Edwards site, they can read the post that goes along with the video telling them what to do.

There's also the scroll bar that allows viewers to click around the video so they can read the call to action if they missed it the first time.

Steve Garfield
http://stevegarfield.com

It's the issues that matter

Apart from being a slick use of online video technology, this appeal is grounded upon very intelligent fundraising psychology.

It recognizes that most donors are indeed driven by passion over issues. In this fundraising appeal, Edwards is "riding the issue" ... as is totally appropriate.

He's not pushing his character, his record, his need to make a good showing in the next FEC report. He's tapping anger and exasperation that people feel about an issue and about -- as they perceive and feel it -- a wrong-headed and unresponsive President. And, along the way, he's positioning himself as our champion.

Not surprising he was an effective trial lawyer! Well done John Edwards.

John Edwards Gives Netroots A Powerful Voice on Iraq

Crossposted from Democrats.com

I'm not supporting a Presidential candidate - and have no plans to do so for quite a while - but I love this new ad by John Edwards.

Why? Because it gives voice to each and every one of us who want Congressional Democrats to stand up to Bush and end the war in Iraq.

Here's the money quote: "send him the same bill again and again - we the people will stand with you." Someone's been reading my mind!

It's easy to see this ad as the handiwork of Edwards' new netroots consultant, Joe Trippi. Trippi made Howard Dean a netroots hero in 2004 and is working to do the same for Edwards.

Trippi believes campaigns should fully embrace and unleash the energy and passion of the netroots, not treat us as an ATM as other campaigns do (Hillary are you listening?). And this ad embraces the netroots almost as much as Ned Lamont's historic ads that featured Kos & Co.

Of course there are dangers to unleashing the netroots, because the GOP-controlled Corporate Media hates us and will do everything they can to destroy us and the candidate we support - just as they did to Howard Dean in 2004.

Trippi's ad avoids the obvious peril of featuring a particular blogger like Kos who can be attacked for a published comment that is controversial, no matter how old or irrelevant. Clearly Edwards learned this lesson from the recent Marcotte/McEwen debacle.

But without a famous blogger, the Edwards ad has remarkable power - the power of honesty and directness from ordinary citizens.

So congratulations to Trippi for a brilliant ad - and to John Edwards for hiring him.

I hope all the other candidates empower their netroots consultants to create even more powerful ads, because the candidate who genuinely empowers and inspires the netroots will sweep to victory in both the primaries and the general election.



© 2008 Personal Democracy Forum | All Rights Reserved |